Permlink Replies: 25 - Last Post: Feb 13, 2009 10:56 AM Last Post By: martinxw
kennedgy

Posts: 21
Registered: 01/19/09
Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 21, 2009 3:50 PM
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
We recently upgraded from Inventor/Vault 2008 to 2009 and have a concern.

When creating a new assembly in 2009 Inventor and inserting Content Center parts
the user is sometimes notified that Content Center files must be checked out.
This happens when local content is out of date, caused when Content used in 2008 is used in 2009.

If the user checks out content center parts, the local components are updated.
My understanding is that it is bad practice to allow all users to Check Out content center files.
If the content is not checked out, it can not be used.

Is this a problem?
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 21, 2009 5:13 PM   in response to: kennedgy in response to: kennedgy
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
were your files migrated before the upgrade?
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 21, 2009 5:19 PM   in response to: joe in response to: joe
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
strike that reply, I just noticed you stated local content.

I wonder if having your users delete the old CC parts from their
workstations might fix this issue...

Any ideas anybody?
kennedgy

Posts: 21
Registered: 01/19/09
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 22, 2009 6:07 PM   in response to: joe in response to: joe
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
Tried deleting local content and it didn't help.
It appears that Content is created in the Vault whenever a component is used.
The Vault files are being updated when 2008 content is used in 2009.

Did we miss a migration step?

I'm also trying to decipher the Vault content folder structure.
We have multiple folders containing the same content.

For example we have the following folders in Vault for hex nuts...
ANSI B18.2.2(02)
ANSI B18.2.2(03)
ANSI B18.2.2(08)
ANSI B18.2.2(09)
ANSI B18.2.2(10)

Some, but not all, content is repeated.
ANSI B18.2.2 -1_2 - 13(3) is in the (08) folder and
ANSI B18.2.2 -1_2 - 13(2) is in the (09) folder.
Both are 1/2" UNC hex nuts.

Can we eliminate the repetition of identical components?
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 22, 2009 7:09 PM   in response to: kennedgy in response to: kennedgy
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
if the local CC files were deleted off the users computer, what should
be happening in different cases is;

1. user checks out an assembly with CC parts out of Vault, which if the
local CC was deleted, Vault should be copying down CC files out of
Vault onto the users computer. This is where migration of current
files in Vault would have taken care of any pre-2009 CC parts in your
Vault.

2. user creates a new assembly and inserts CC parts into it. The CC
parts are now being created from scratch. As long as that is being done
thru Inv 2009, the CC parts will be in version 2009 format.

Content Center parts are created on the users computer from scratch (not
in Vault), and are not put into Vault until the user checks them in.

Deleting all CC files off a users computer (assuming that everything
was checked in first to avoid problems) should take care of this.

As for the multiple files of various hex nuts, all I can think of is
different versions of Inventor over the years possibly created
different paths each time.

I myself would be very hesitant about deleting any CC parts from within
Vault regardless of the repetition due to the fact that anything in
Vault now is tied to or dependent on something else which is also in
Vault.

Try this, on one of the systems that is experiencing this problem,
have the user check in all files they have checked out. Have the user
then go back and delete the *entire* local CC folder, not sure of your
paths so double check first. Then have the user go thru and make sure
any Inventor files are deleted or moved to somewhere outside of the
working folder.

Side note about deleting CC parts, after the above steps are taken, it
might be good to do a complete search of their C:\ drive for any and
all Inventor .ipt files to see if there are some "stray" CC parts
anywhere. Some people may have copied files to other locations or
maybe were practicing questionable modeling practices, you never know!

Then try to check out an assembly with CC parts that you know has given
you problems before and see what happens.

possibilities...

Everybody is on 2009 now right? Nobody is accidentally starting up 2008
are they (assuming you have that installed still)?

Project files OK? During the upgrade process, was your Project file/s
migrated *and* all users got a new copy of the Project file/s?

Throwing out ideas here...
martinxw

Posts: 27
Registered: 11/28/06
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 23, 2009 8:54 AM   in response to: joe in response to: joe
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
Re: point 1:

If local CC was deleted and than user go to Inventor and use check-out from vault for assembly with CC, Inventor shows the message - CC files are missing.

Vault add-in in Inventor is not able copy CC files to local from Vault.

But I don't know why, because Vault has associations between the asssembly and this CC files.
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 23, 2009 2:54 PM   in response to: martinxw in response to: martinxw
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
Some how that doesn't sound right.

I could have sworn if a person who has never worked on an assembly
before which is in Vault and contained CC parts, and that person has
never created the particular CC parts that are within that assembly in
any other assembly, then when that person checks out said assembly with
CC parts from Vault, that Vault should be copying down the CC parts to
that users computer.

If the entire CC folder was deleted, Vault should be recreating the
folder structure as needed on that system when files are checked out.
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 23, 2009 6:47 PM   in response to: martinxw in response to: martinxw
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
just ran a test on 2009

1. created a simple two CC part assy with a nut and bolt.

2. checked in the assembly to Vault (checking the delete files option
apparently doesn't go thru and delete CC parts, only the .iam file)

3. removed the en-US folder from C:\Vault\Work\Content Center Files
which contains the two CC parts in their respective folders and placed
it on my desktop

4. thru Inventor, File -> Open From Vault and choose my assy. It then
prompted me to check out all files.

The results were, no error msg about missing CC parts, it just copied
down the CC parts from Vault to C:\Vault\Work\Content Center
Files\en-US\ into their respective folders.

When I switch over to Vault in the browser inside Inventor, I see just
the assy is checked out, not the CC parts.

Of coarse I do not have any pre-2009 files on this computer so I have
no way of testing with 2008 CC parts in either the Vault or working
folders.
martinxw

Posts: 27
Registered: 11/28/06
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 26, 2009 2:49 PM   in response to: joe in response to: joe
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
Attachment vaultCC.doc (202.5 KB)
Hello Joe

I try your test too. I tested it in Inventor Professional 2009.
See attachment.

CC is missing. Vault add-in in Inventor wasn't able to copy CC file from filestore to local hard drive.
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 26, 2009 4:39 PM   in response to: martinxw in response to: martinxw
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
The only thing I did different was when I was opening from Vault, I did
not specify "Check out all".

I let the next screen which pops up and asks if I wanted to check out
all and choose yes.

I don't have an answer as to why your CC parts were not copied down
from Vault.

Assume this situation, you are the person who created this assembly
with one solid body and 4 CC parts. You've checked in the assembly into
Vault.

Another person on a completely different workstation who has never
created any assembly with those exact same CC parts now checks your
assembly out of Vault. What should happen?

I would suggest doing that sort of test with another co-worker and see
what the results are.

HTH
martinxw

Posts: 27
Registered: 11/28/06
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 27, 2009 8:36 AM   in response to: joe in response to: joe
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
I tryed your way - didn't specify "Checked out all".

I let the next screen which pops up and asks if I wanted to check out all and choose yes, too.

And than same dialog asked for CC file was appeared :o(((

Next I checked in on first PC and go to another PC - logged to different user - and in Inventor try open from Vault.

I have got same result as in first case.


I'm interested in what I have different from you.

I'll try it in english version of Inventor. Let we see what happened :o))
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 27, 2009 1:53 PM   in response to: martinxw in response to: martinxw
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
I used a newly installed and default configuration of Inventor and
Vault 2009 for my test.

This is the web site I followed in creating my Project file and
configuring Vault and Inventor;

http://mfgcommunity.autodesk.com/blogs/blog/view/5/Using_Autodesk_Vault_with_Single_1/

Let me know if there is anything specific you want to compare between
our two systems.
martinxw

Posts: 27
Registered: 11/28/06
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 27, 2009 2:35 PM   in response to: joe in response to: joe
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
My results are:

Inventor 2009 EN (english):
CC file is copyed to local hard drive. It is fine and correct.

Inventor 2009 CS (czech):
CC file ISN'T copyed to local hard drive. It is fail.
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 27, 2009 3:08 PM   in response to: martinxw in response to: martinxw
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
I've never reported a bug, but this needs to get to Adsk's attention
somehow.
kennedgy

Posts: 21
Registered: 01/19/09
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 28, 2009 3:55 PM   in response to: martinxw in response to: martinxw
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
Some Vaults are set up to restrict user access to Content Center files. Do you both allow check out of Content Center part files, or is that limited to admin only?

This does sound like a software glitch.

I also found that if we use "place component" rather than "place from content center" we are able to avoid the bug (allows "get latest version"). This does require that content center files are on the workstation hard drive, and also requires browsing unrecognizable file names rather than the nice graphical interface of content center.
martinxw

Posts: 27
Registered: 11/28/06
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Feb 13, 2009 10:56 AM   in response to: kennedgy in response to: kennedgy
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
Both instalation are clear from DVD, no extra settings.
Both login under administartor user to OS and to Vault too.

So, why in one language version it is working and in second isn't?

Where can I set check out content centre files? I searched this ability, but I couldn't find it.
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 22, 2009 7:22 PM   in response to: kennedgy in response to: kennedgy
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
On Thu, 22 Jan 2009 18:07:17 +0000
kennedgy wrote:

The
Vault files are being updated when 2008 content is used in 2009. Did
we miss a migration step?


Clarification about this. Over the years thru different Inventor
versions, as people create CC parts, they are stored on the users
computer. When a person checks files in, they may or may not be going
back and deleting all files. If they are deleting files after
check-in, they may not be deleting CC parts.

So you may have alot of stray, old versions of CC parts on the users
computer.

Migration usually only takes place on the actual Vault server, not on
users computers.

I really suspect there are some old versions of CC parts on the users
computers (in possibly multiple locations) which could be giving you
grief.
kennedgy

Posts: 21
Registered: 01/19/09
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 22, 2009 8:51 PM   in response to: joe in response to: joe
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
Thanks for all the tips, Joe.

I think I've got a handle on where we are at.
Here goes...

I looked a little harder at the "duplicate" content and found that though the file names are the same, the components are different (1/2" hex nut, 1/2" heavy hex nut, 1/2" thick hex nut, etc.)

Creating new, previously unused content works fine.

Our real hang up is that we did not migrate the content in Vault as part of the upgrade.
Now the users have to check out content center (and any other 2008) parts when assembled in order to migrate.
They can be checked right back in with the only change being the migration.

If we have mixed 2008/2009 (and possibly older) files in the Vault can we still migrate easily to 2009?
Other than concerns about the integrity of content center files are there concerns migrating files as used?
I saw a bulletin elsewhere on the Autodesk site and they compared "Implicit" and "Explicit" migration.
Autodesk recommends migrating the files as used (implicit).

http://images.autodesk.com/adsk/files/migrating_autodesk_inventor_data_in_autodesk_vault.pdf
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 22, 2009 9:34 PM   in response to: kennedgy in response to: kennedgy
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
ah, yes if the files were not migrated then this might be the issue.

Sorry I don't have any experience in migrating so I do not know if
there will be issues with anything previous to 2008 files.

One way to find out is to backup the Vault, then attempt the
migration. Nothing to loose except for your IT/IS staff loosing some
hair or it turns grey on them!
ariesk

Posts: 2
Registered: 11/07/06
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 23, 2009 1:53 PM   in response to: kennedgy in response to: kennedgy
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
Just to let you know you're not alone. The same problem overhere. Upgraded Inventor and Vault 2008 to 2009 and CC parts want to check out. Our upgrade may went differently however. All new systems and new Vault server with 'clean' 2009 installs. Exported libraries from the old 2008 to the new 2009 vault server. Imported, migrated, ready! Not!
On the clean (formatted etc.) local sytems, CC files want to be checked out. Even after Checking out the entire CC folder from the vault to a local machine and checking back in, clearing the local CC folder (what shouldn't be a problem in my opinion, as CC parts are re-created), a new check out is wanted.
Our reseller will come in and take look, but if you guys have any ideas, I'll surely try them first....and offcourse if we solve it, we'll let you know.
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 23, 2009 2:42 PM   in response to: ariesk in response to: ariesk
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
On Fri, 23 Jan 2009 13:53:00 +0000
ariesk wrote:

clearing the local CC
folder (what shouldn't be a problem in my opinion, as CC parts are
re-created)


I'm not 100% positive so I could be wrong, but I thought that if
Inventor found an existing CC part already on a users computer it just
used that copy instead of creating it from metadata or what ever it's
called.
ariesk

Posts: 2
Registered: 11/07/06
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 23, 2009 3:00 PM   in response to: joe in response to: joe
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
That is correct, but not the problem. The issue is that with an empty local CC folder, the newly created CC part (or in effect that 'metadata') differs from the vaulted CC parts which ought to be up to date through the migration process... and all libraries (metadata) are 'updated' through the migration...right? So how come they're different?
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 23, 2009 3:13 PM   in response to: ariesk in response to: ariesk
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
On Fri, 23 Jan 2009 15:00:36 +0000
ariesk wrote:

That is correct, but not the problem. The issue is that with an empty
local CC folder, the newly created CC part (or in effect that
'metadata') differs from the vaulted CC parts which ought to be up to
date through the migration process... and all libraries (metadata)
are 'updated' through the migration...right? So how come they're
different?


I think I can see the issue you are pointing out.

Libraries are installed with the newest version of Inventor, not
migrated I believe, but I understand how you are stating it. However
you have brought up an instance where it is possible for a newly
created CC part that may not/wont jive with a CC part that has been
migrated in Vault.

TGIF
kennedgy

Posts: 21
Registered: 01/19/09
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 23, 2009 7:23 PM   in response to: ariesk in response to: ariesk
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
To be sure we are talking about the same things, we did move all our data to the 2009 server.
When I say "migrate", I mean updating the file format of parts and assemblies from version 2008 Inventor to 2009 Inventor (which we did not do).
Migration happens in the background when an individual file (2008 format) is opened in 2009.

Here is what I think is happening...
When using content center, new part files are created in the Vault if that particular part has never been used before.
We have no problem with previously unused components.
When inserting a 2008 format component, Inventor requires the file format to be migrated to 2009.
Migration requires the file to be checked out.
After a user migrates the component to 2009, that user can check the component back in to Vault and use it normally without check out.
We are having problems (check out required) if a users local copy is 2008 and the Vault copy is 2009. Still requires check out.

We are planning to migrate all the Vault content center components with Task Scheduler.
I am thinking we need to go through and purge or update local content on all workstations after this.
joe
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Jan 23, 2009 7:41 PM   in response to: kennedgy in response to: kennedgy
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
On Fri, 23 Jan 2009 19:23:44 +0000
kennedgy wrote:

I am thinking we need to go through
and purge or update local content on all workstations after this.


Good idea. If your users have all files checked into Vault (and they
do not have any models stored on their hard-drive which could contain
CC parts, either in or out of the working folder), you should be able to
just go in and delete the folder called en-US in their Content Center
Files (or what ever name it is) folder.

Doing it the way I described above, you might be able to avoid
migrating the Vault files with Task Scheduler - but you would still have
to check out CC parts on a as needed basis in order to get them up to
2009 versions.

Regardless of which ever direction you want to go, it would be best to
go thru and get all the older versions of CC files off every bodies
computer.
postventa-msd@a...

Posts: 64
Registered: 02/19/07
Re: Vault Upgrade 2008 to 2009 causing Content Center problems
Posted: Feb 9, 2009 12:33 PM   in response to: kennedgy in response to: kennedgy
  Click to reply to this thread Reply
Hi Sirs,

I am having the same problem. Our customer has thousands of 3D models in CC Library, motors, threads, etc,... personalized.

After migrating, CC doesn't runs well. I'm thinking in having a normal folder inside project path that no cause us more migrating problems.

The idea of content center is genial, the performance is poor. (Have you tried an update a family of iparts? It is a hell).

Tomas Pascual
Regards